As someone who’s spent countless hours both in the field and inevitably discussing gun setups with other homesteaders, hunters, and preppers, I’ve found that one of the many debates that consistently sparks strong opinions is the choice between pistol grips and plain stocks on turkey guns.
This isn’t just a matter of aesthetics or tradition. Both have their merits, and the right choice for you depends on what you value most in terms of comfort, control, and adaptability. Let’s break it down in detail, so you can make an informed decision based on facts rather than just preference.
The Case for Pistol Grips
Pistol grips have gained popularity, especially among hunters looking for increased control and ergonomics. While they may look out of place to some on a traditional shotgun, they have real, tangible benefits that are worth considering.
Comfort is King
When you’re hunkered down for hours, waiting patiently for that perfect shot, comfort becomes a crucial factor. A pistol grip can make a world of difference here. The ergonomic shape naturally fits the hand, reducing the strain on your wrist and forearm. It helps keep your hand in a neutral position, which is a relief during those long sessions where you’re sitting up against a tree, keeping a low profile. The angle of the grip also lets you maneuver the shotgun more easily in cramped or awkward spaces, something that’s harder to do with a traditional stock.
Enhanced Trigger Control
One of the main advantages of a pistol grip is the improved trigger control it offers. With your hand positioned more naturally, you get better leverage, allowing for a cleaner, more consistent pull. This can be a game-changer when your shot requires precision, particularly when you’re twisted around or shooting from an odd angle. The design minimizes the movement in your trigger finger, reducing the likelihood of jerking the trigger and missing your shot.
Slip Prevention: A Hidden Advantage
Even the most seasoned hunter will admit that there are moments when exhaustion hits, and you might doze off, even if just for a second. In those moments, keeping your gun steady is critical. A pistol grip can help prevent the shotgun from slipping off your lap or knee because of the extra control it provides. It’s easier to grip and reposition quickly, even if you’re half-awake. Trust me, in those sleepy early morning hunts, this feature can come in extremely handy.
Adjustability for Custom Fit
If you like gear that can adapt to your body or the situation, pistol grips usually come paired with adjustable stocks. This adjustability allows you to shorten the length of pull—sometimes down to 11 inches—which is a huge advantage when you’re maneuvering in tight spaces or need to react quickly. You can also raise or lower the comb height, which helps when you’re using optics or red-dot sights. Having the right fit can be the difference between a hit or a miss, especially in fast-paced scenarios.
The Argument for Plain Stocks
While pistol grips offer a lot of modern advantages, there’s a reason plain stocks have been the go-to design for decades, if not centuries. They remain a favorite for many turkey hunters because of their reliability and versatility.
Simplicity and Reliability
Sometimes, simple is better. Plain stocks are incredibly straightforward. There’s no need to worry about extra adjustments or moving parts—just point, aim, and shoot. This simplicity translates into fewer things that can go wrong. In the field, where conditions can be unpredictable, reliability is key. A plain stock is as reliable as they come, and it’s often the choice for those who don’t want any added complexity to their setup.
Weight and Bulk: A Major Consideration
One thing that often gets overlooked in the pistol grip debate is the added weight and bulk they bring to your gun. Most pistol grip setups tend to be heavier due to the extra materials and components. If you’re trekking through rugged terrain, carrying that extra weight can really start to wear on you. A plain stock, on the other hand, is usually lighter and more streamlined. For those long hunts where every ounce counts, a lighter setup can help preserve your stamina.
The Appeal of Tradition
There’s no denying the sentimental value of a classic wooden or synthetic plain stock. For many, hunting is a tradition passed down through generations, and a plain stock feels like a connection to that heritage. It’s part of the experience, and for some, using anything other than a traditional stock just wouldn’t feel right. There’s something comforting about sticking to what’s worked for decades.
Versatility Beyond Turkey Hunting
Another often overlooked benefit of plain stocks is their versatility. While pistol grips excel in certain specialized situations, they can feel out of place for other types of hunting. A plain-stocked turkey gun can easily transition into a reliable shotgun for deer, waterfowl, or even small game. This adaptability makes it a more practical choice if you want one shotgun that can handle a variety of hunting scenarios.
My Two Cents
After years of experience using both pistol grips and plain stocks, here’s my take: there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. It really depends on your specific needs, hunting style, and personal preferences. Pistol grips offer superior comfort and control, especially for those long, drawn-out hunts where ergonomics matter. On the other hand, plain stocks shine in their simplicity, lighter weight, and adaptability across various types of hunting.
If I had to choose for myself, I’d lean toward the pistol grip for those extended turkey hunts where I know I’ll be sitting still for long periods. The comfort and control just make it easier for me to stay focused and ready for the moment of truth. But, if I were packing light and wanted a more versatile tool for multiple hunts, a plain stock would be my go-to.
In the end, the best advice I can give is to try both and see what feels right in your hands. Practice with your setup, make sure it fits your hunting style, and most importantly, get out there and use it. After all, the only way to truly know what works best is to put it to the test in the field.
